Arrowsmlft.gif (338 bytes)Previous Table of Contents NextArrowsmrt.gif (337 bytes)

KEY PERSON PROTECTION

The success of a closely held business often depends on the personal services of key owner-employees and key non-owner-employees. The loss of a key employee�s services due to death or disability will probably result in a loss of income, at least temporarily, to the closely held business. In addition, the business could incur increased expenses if a replacement employee has to be recruited at a higher salary and requires extensive training. This key employee exposure should be considered to protect the income of the business.

The first step in handling this risk is to identify the key employees. Key employees have several characteristics distinguishing them from other employees, including the following:

 

 

Identifying the key employee might be more difficult than it seems. The owners of a closely held business are generally material participants in the business and can be classified as key employees. But beyond the owners the key employee risk is often overlooked. The business owners might uncover this risk by considering the damage to the business that would occur if a specific managerial employee was absent for longer than the normal vacation period.

Valuing the Key Employee

Determining the key employee�s value to the closely held business is even more speculative than the valuation of the business itself. The actual valuation method depends on the characteristic of the employee that creates the key employee status. Determining the value of the key employee who attracts substantial business might be relatively easy. The net income resulting from the business he or she produces in excess of the amount of net income that could be expected from a similarly situated but less effective employee could be capitalized in some manner. Or if business goodwill is attributed to one key employee, the income level above the amount expected for a similar business can be attributed to that employee. This income attributed to goodwill can be capitalized to arrive at a current value for the employee.

 

Example: A business currently has $500,000 of tangible assets and generates $100,000 a year in net income. Similarly situated businesses have a rate of return on tangible assets of 10 percent. In this case $50,000 of income can be attributed to capital, and $50,000 can be attributed to goodwill and the management skill of the key employee. Using business valuation capitalization methods, we can capitalize the $50,000 of earnings at the 10 percent expected return rate and reach a value for the key employee. The capitalization factor in this case is 10 (100 ÷ 10).

 

 

$50,000 x 10 = $500,000

 

In this case the key employee�s value to the business is $500,000.

 

The value of a key employee, particularly when more than one key employee is present, is usually more difficult to determine than in the example above. The firm may have to consider various subjective factors to arrive at a proxy for thekey employee�s value. For example, the firm should consider replacement salaries and the training required for a replacement employee to become effective. A simple approach might be to take the key employee and pick some multiple of current salary as a proxy for his or her value.

Key Employee Life Insurance

A business can purchase life insurance on the life of the key employee to cover the risk of an income loss and/or increase in expenses resulting from the key employee�s death. Term insurance can be purchased if the primary concern is the key employee�s dollar value to the business. Decreasing term might be appropriate because the key employee exposure decreases as the insured approaches retirement since the business can expect to have his or her services for a fewer number of years.

Key employee insurance, however, is usually coupled with some other purpose such as providing a retirement benefit for the key employee. Permanent life insurance is typically purchased to meet this objective. The life insurance death benefit will be received by the business as indemnification for the income

TABLE 12-4
Comparison of Methods for Inclusion of Life Insurance in the Compensation Plan

 

 

Qualified

Plans

Nonqualified Plan Benefits

 

DBOs

 

Sec. 79 Plans

Sec. 162

Bonus Plans

Split-Dollar Plans

Reverse Split- Dollar Plans

Corporate

Income Tax

Deduction

Up to incidental limits

Benefits

deductible

when paid

Benefits

deductible

when paid

Yes, if reasonable compensation

Yes, if reasonable compensation

No deduction

No deduction

Current Income Taxation to Employee

PS 58 costs less employee contribution

No

No

Table 1 costs for coverage above $50,000

Full amount of bonus

PS 58 cost less employee contribution

Uncertain

 

Employee�s Share of Death Benefit

Full proceeds

Full deferred-
compensation

benefit

Full proceeds

Full proceeds

Full proceeds

Amount at risk (traditional plan)

Cash surrender value (full proceeds after RSD plan terminates)

Income Taxation of

Benefits Received by Heirs

Tax free to extent of amount at risk

Yes

 

Yes

No

No

No

No

Proceeds in Employee�s Estate for Estate Tax

Purposes

Yes

Yes

No, unless the decedent possessed living non-qualified benefits

Yes, unless assigned to third-party owner more than 3 years prior to death

Yes, unless assigned to third-party owner more than 3 years prior to death

Yes, unless assigned to third-party owner more than 3 years prior to death

Yes, unless assigned to third-party owner more than 3 years prior to death (estate gets a deduction for amount of death benefit payable to corporation)

Employee Access to Cash Surrender
Value

No, unless profit-sharying plan (indirect access through plan loan provisions in other qualified plans)

No

No

N/A

Yes

No, unless a rollout occurs

Yes, unless restricted by plan agreement

loss and/or increase in expenses resulting from the key employee�s death. If the insured survives to retirement, the corporation can use the cash surrender value to fund a deferred-compensation retirement benefit. Another approach is for the business to transfer the policy to the employee at retirement.

The business should be the owner and beneficiary of key employee life insurance. This should pose no insurable interest problems since the business will suffer a pecuniary loss at the death of the key employee. The premiums for key employee insurance will be nondeductible, while death benefits will be received tax free. An additional benefit of key employee insurance is that no accumulated-earnings tax problems should result since the accumulation of earnings to insure the key employee death risk will meet the reasonable-business-needs test. For incorporated businesses key employee life insurance may, however, increase exposure to the alternative minimum corporate tax discussed later.

Arrowsmlft.gif (338 bytes)Previous TopArrowsm.gif (337 bytes) NextArrowsmrt.gif (337 bytes)